Using a Reserve Fund Study as Evidence if an Alberta Board Faces an Oppressive Conduct Claim

Section 67 of Alberta’s Condominium Property Act addresses improper conduct, including conduct that is oppressive or unfairly prejudicial or that unfairly disregards an interested party’s interests. This article explains, in plain language, how a reserve fund study may appear in an evidence file — and what it cannot do. It is not legal advice.

Oppressive conduct, under section 67 of Alberta’s Condominium Property Act, refers to running a corporation’s business affairs, or exercising the board’s powers, in a manner that is oppressive or unfairly prejudicial to, or that unfairly disregards the interests of, an interested party. This guide explains how a reserve fund study may appear in an oppressive conduct file, and what it cannot do. It is not legal advice.

Need a Reserve Fund Study in Alberta?

Brookstone Engineering is a reserve fund study provider with an APEGA-licensed Professional Engineer (P.Eng.) serving Edmonton Metro, Calgary Metro and Central Alberta. Request a Reserve Fund Study

Key Takeaways

  • Section 67 lets the Court remedy “improper conduct”, which includes non-compliance with the Act, the regulations or the bylaws, and conduct that is oppressive or unfairly prejudicial to, or unfairly disregards the interests of, an interested party.
  • A reserve fund study is one document in that kind of file. It can show what the board knew; it does not defeat a claim on its own.
  • The records that usually matter are the study and report current at the time, the approved plan and proof owners received it, the minutes, and what was actually spent or deferred.
  • Following a current study with recorded reasons can be useful context. Having no current study, or ignoring one without a recorded reason, can also appear in the file.
  • Being late on the first study (2 years after registration) or the five-year review is a statutory problem in its own right.
  • Involve the corporation’s counsel early. The engineer explains the report; counsel owns procedure and any response.

Alberta boards sometimes hear that a professionally prepared reserve fund study will “protect” them if an owner later alleges oppressive conduct. That overstates what the document can do.

Section 67 of the Condominium Property Act gives the Court a remedy where it is satisfied that “improper conduct” has taken place. Improper conduct includes non-compliance with the Act, the regulations or the bylaws. It also includes running the corporation’s business affairs, or exercising the board’s powers, in a manner that is oppressive or unfairly prejudicial to, or that unfairly disregards the interests of, an interested party. The Court may appoint an investigator, direct that the conduct stop, give directions to prevent it continuing, award compensation for loss, award costs, or make any other order it considers appropriate (s.67(2)). Interim relief is available (s.67(3)). The application is brought by an interested party: an owner, the corporation, a board member, a registered mortgagee, or another person with a registered interest in a unit (s.67(1)(b)).

Brookstone Engineering prepares reserve fund studies; it does not act as the corporation’s counsel, and nothing here is legal advice.

Low-slope roof membrane with dark patched areas around roof drains and penetrations

Which study and minute records are typically relevant — and which are not

Records that often matter, if a funding, special-levy, or deferred-work decision is in issue, include:

  • The reserve fund study and reserve fund report that were current at the time of the decision, including the provider’s qualifications and the statements the Regulation requires.
  • The board-approved reserve fund plan, and evidence that owners received a copy as required.
  • Minutes and resolutions that show the board considered the report or plan, and why it followed or departed from a recommendation.
  • Contribution records, tenders, and invoices that show what was actually spent or deferred.
  • The annual report on the reserve fund that the corporation provides to owners as part of the annual general meeting package.
  • Later updates, if conditions or costs had changed.
Edge of a concrete balcony slab with a metal railing post above a ground-floor patio door

Records that usually carry less weight:

  • A study completed after the disputed decision, unless counsel is using it for a different purpose.
  • Marketing claims about “engineering-backed defence” with no link to the actual decision.
  • A study that was never approved into a plan, or a plan that was never shared with owners as required.
  • Informal advice that never made it into the report or the minutes.

For the statutory study requirements themselves, use the requirements guide.

How following — or ignoring — the study can appear

Segmental concrete block retaining wall along a landscaped bed

If the board approved a plan based on a current report, funded recommended contributions, and documented why a project was advanced, deferred, or phased, the study can be context: it shows the board had professional planning information in front of it.

If the board had no current study, or had a report and consistently ignored recommended contributions or urgent work without a recorded reason, that absence or departure can also appear in a file. The study is not a verdict. It is evidence of what the board knew, or could have known, and what it did next.

Exterior stair to a second-floor walkway with a chain hung across the steps

Section 67 also covers non-compliance with the Act, the regulations or the bylaws. A corporation that is simply late on its first reserve fund study, report and plan (due no later than 2 years after the condominium plan is registered, under section 24 of the Condominium Property Regulation) or on its five-year review (section 30) has a statutory problem whether or not anyone uses the word “oppression.” Fixing the planning file is the first practical step; it is not a substitute for legal advice once a claim is on the table.

Vertical crack in a concrete foundation wall filled with white sealant above a stone bed

When to involve the corporation’s counsel

Involve counsel early if an interested party has threatened or started a s.67 application, if the board is about to make a funding decision that departs sharply from the current plan, or if the corporation’s study or plan is missing and a dispute is already live. The engineer can explain the report. Counsel should own procedure, privilege, and any response.

Do not ask the reserve fund study provider to write a legal opinion, to predict a Court outcome, or to “bulletproof” the board. Ask them to prepare a complete, current study if one is due, and to be available to explain their assumptions if counsel needs that explanation.

Close view of patched exterior stucco with fresh repair material over older cladding

Frequently Asked Questions

What is section 67, in one paragraph?

Section 67 of the Condominium Property Act is a Court-ordered remedy for “improper conduct.” That term includes non-compliance with the Act, the regulations or the bylaws, and also the conduct of the corporation’s affairs or the exercise of the board’s powers in a manner that is oppressive or unfairly prejudicial to, or that unfairly disregards the interests of, an interested party. Interested parties include an owner, the corporation, a board member, a registered mortgagee, or another person with a registered interest in a unit. The Court may, among other things, give directions, award compensation, and award costs. This is a summary, not advice.

Will a current study defeat a section 67 application?

No. A study is one document. The Court looks at conduct. A current study may help explain a funding or timing decision; it will not automatically defeat a claim, and ignoring a study may also be part of the story.

Does the CDRT replace section 67?

No. The Tribunal is a separate process under ss.68.1 and following. Some disputes may go to the Tribunal; s.67 remains a Court remedy. Counsel should advise which forum, if any, applies.

When must an Alberta condominium corporation complete its first reserve fund study?

Section 24 of the Condominium Property Regulation requires the corporation to meet the study, report, plan and owner-copy requirements in section 23(1) to (6) no later than 2 years after the condominium plan is registered.

How often must the study be redone?

Section 30 of the Regulation requires a new reserve fund study, a new reserve fund report, an approved reserve fund plan and copies to owners on or before 5 years from the day the most recent reserve fund plan was approved. Provincial guidance also says a study must be completed no less than every 5 years.

Can the reserve fund study provider act as the board’s legal adviser?

No. The provider prepares the study and can explain its assumptions. Procedure, privilege and any response to a claim belong with the corporation’s counsel.

Sources

  1. Condominium Property Act, RSA 2000, c C-22, s.67 (Alberta King’s Printer)
  2. Condominium Property Regulation, Alta Reg 168/2000, ss.23, 24 and 30 (Alberta King’s Printer)
  3. Government of Alberta — Reserve funds

Reserve Fund Studies Across Alberta

We provide reserve fund studies for condominium corporations across Alberta, including Edmonton, Calgary and Red Deer.

Ready to get started? Get a Quote →

Request a quote for a Reserve Fund Study from Brookstone Engineering.

Related resources